It's a quick death, God help us all.
It is not.
Book Review: Confessions of a Norse Nerd 
11th-May-2008 06:16 pm
master!, loving lovers love, rainbow bowtie unicorn kitty, go on go on, revolver awfulkittyhot, jet: quality, zuko: scowl, zuko: blossoms, pbj: writer, deerhead, eleanor, jet: lost boy, jack attack!, tos: cat person, howl: wistful, MEGALOSAURUS!, howl: out of it, leyendecker: smarten up, chatterton, howl: smile, hahn: all gave some, nelius: scary manic, zuko: beaten not broken, bernard: anything else, tab hunter says, black swan, patrick red, hahn: little boy blue, zhahn kissy, imbri: unamused, green khnopff, jet: like a bird on the wire, zhaolove, jet: freedom isn't free, doctor: bitch, obnoxious and disliked, tos: boyfriends, magritte lion, tos: what now?, rozin: setting sun, master: no i won't!, ft: careful now, a proper gentleman, jet: canon, scotty, squid with the most, rozin: bffs, HH: hornbush BFFS, hahn: what's your problem?, greatheart, hahn: pft, sam beckett, leyendecker: gentlemanly, zhao: love me and despair, batman: sontag said it's evidence, jet: hearts, moz: eek and riah, amor vincit omnia, nelius: destroy everything you touch, zuko: rozin lol, mortality by gorey, ds9: julian journals, patrick, sokka: art post, reian: i are an hero!, rozin: GAY, OZAI, jet: bad idea, master doctor <3, leyendecker: a day at the races, sokka: help!, jarvis: pink, caesar, pbj silly, dancin sozin, baron: tips hat, jet: classy & cowboy, hahn: live action, fan girl, imbri: too much man for you, bernard: FANTASTIC, nelius: dot dot dot, ofah: local millionaires, perfect: frieda, fantastic power!, zhahn: live action, bato: hakoda, reian: the boy who could speak to birds, tm: hells yeah!!, unicorn, magritte rose, flame red squid, atreyu, leyendecker: sporting life, mamegoma, revolver awfulhot, rj: pretty for his man, zuko: no means no, rozin: hug, hearts flowers, greatheart: curious!, bernard: gold star, pbj clumsy, pbj giggle, jarvis: bookish, magritte bird, baron: smile, doctor: time lord's best friend, bato: noodles, sozin: you and me how about it?, zhahn, aang: community service, HH: Is it evening?, sokka: pipe, lionel roar!, bato: hearts, magritte men, pbj sigh, hey sailor, swordgirl, ds9: reality has no place, party milk!
Hmm, I'm feeling pretty chatty today. Two posts so far! Anyway, this week I had a media disappointment--you know, when you're really into something and then it suddenly takes a horrible turn (a few of you know what I'm talking about)--so I decided to ignore this entertainment setback and focus on that elusive positive.

So--I read a pretty good YA book. Runemarks by Joanne Harris. It's based on Norse mythology, which is a favorite mythology of mine. I never seem to post reviews in here, but hey, why not!


As I mentioned, Norse mythology is very dear to my heart, for no particular reason except that I really, really like it. One of my dearest wishes is to someday write a novel or draw a comic based on those stories. However, I am certainly not an expert on the subject, and my thoughts about the myths are more based on personal preference and feeling than on scholarship.

Basically, Runemarks is set in the world of the Norse myths, long after Ragnarok. The gods are largely believed to be dead, or at least gone forever. The main character is a girl named Maddy, who was born with a runemark on her hand. She was a good protagonist--fun to read about and easy to identity with.

Now, I am very picky about my Norse-based stories. Particularly where the characterization of one particular god is concerned. The truth is, I am absolutely bonkers about Loki. I fanatically adore him, and I get supremely irritated if I don't like an author's characterization of him, which is most of the time. This is completely irrational and idiosyncratic of me. But I really hate pure boring villain Loki. I like Loki full of spirit and fire and mischief, the changeable trickster who was Odin's brother as well as his enemy. Torn between Chaos and Order, unpredictable and fascinating. I did not enjoy Neil Gaiman's Loki, but I read that book so long ago that I can't actually discuss why that was. Sorry, I am a harsh Loki fan!

I love trickster gods, can you tell?

Runemarks actually had great Loki characterization, so I was thrilled. He was deceitful and treacherous and up to all his old tricks, and all the Æsir and Vanir wanted to kill him--but he was still somehow likable and sympathetic and always getting out of tight places just when you thought he was done for.

Her Odin was great, too. Oh oh, and I absolutely loved her use of Balder. It was perfect and satisfying. It actually made me tear up. Oh, Balder. And Heimdall, ha ha, I love him. I was less happy with her Hel and Jormungand, but hey, we all have different takes on the myths, and a great Loki will make me forgive a lot.

Also, her choice for the villain of the piece was very interesting! (Not Loki, thankfully.) And I was actually happy with how things turned out.

I had a few problems with the pacing at the end, but it wasn't a big deal. And it might have been nice to see Fenrir and Sleipnir, but that's not even a criticism, I'm just silly.

Now I'm all Norsed up! All Norsed up and nowhere to go, oh no.
Comments 
11th-May-2008 11:27 pm (UTC)
Oooh, I want to read this! Of course, my interest in the Norse myths are largely warped and shaped by Wagner's adaption for his operas, and I'm all about Odin and the Valkyries (who probably aren't in this), but it sounds like a good read.
12th-May-2008 06:02 am (UTC)
I hope you like it, if you do get a chance to read it!

My interest in Norse myths is similarly warped, if only by my own zany preferences, so I understand completely.

No, the Valkyries aren't in this, sadly--that's something else I would have liked to see! Like I said, I did have a few problems with the story, but overall it was a lot of fun. I was happy to see a YA book based on Norse mythology. I am sure there are more out there, but this was the first I've read.
11th-May-2008 11:45 pm (UTC)
Man, I have such a weakness for good YA fantasy. I need to check this out. Sadly I am not at all knowledgeable about Norse mythology, but it is definitely intriguing.

I might need to take a mythology break, though, since I just took a Greek myth exam.

Neil Gaiman's Loki frightened me. But Neil Gaiman has a tendency to, um, do that.
12th-May-2008 05:54 am (UTC)
I love good YA fantasy, too. I just picked this one up on a whim, and it was much better than I expected (I'm such a pessimist, haha).

If you do read it at some point, I hope you like it! Knowing about Norse mythology probably does help, but I don't think it's necessary to appreciate the book. I can understand about needing a mythology break, though.

If I remember correctly, Gaiman's Loki bored me. I'd rather be frightened! :D
12th-May-2008 01:02 am (UTC)
Haha, Norsed up!
I'm right in there with you regarding Loki - and vicariously in there with you regarding your media disappointment!

I have to say, you make Runemarks sounds a good read - and I'm glad to hear you were happy with how things turned out.
Good books are good fun!

Haha, that was asinine, but it was well meant - I'm a bit bouncy myself. <3
12th-May-2008 05:57 am (UTC)
Oh Loki! That god is trouble! Ha ha, I know my preferred type of Loki is not the "right" one, but I love him best anyway. <3

Well, if you ever get a chance to read Runemarks, I hope you like it. It was indeed a good, fun read!

Lately I am almost surprised to like something! I am picky in such an unpredictable way.

Ha ha, and I meant the falling down the stairs kind of bouncy, like Zuzu.
12th-May-2008 03:37 am (UTC)
I AM IN AGREEMENT WITH YOU REGARDING TRICKSTER GODS!
Any tricksters really...
Anansi, Loki, Coyote, and even Brer Rabbit!
(Hee, and isn't there a story about Anansi tricking the tiger out of his balls at a watering hole? XDDD)

In a way I was on Loki's side regarding Baldr but that was back when I hated popular people. =p Now I just feel sad for him. No matter how nice you are and how loved there will always be someone who hates you enough to want you dead. =\ SOBERING THOUGHT!

I wasn't as interested in the Norse gods as I was in the less powerful non-humans like trolls, frost giants, and huldra or hulderfolk. Even the stories about how they tried to keep the dead from coming back are fascinating!

I'm glad you found a Norse gods story you enjoyed! =D
12th-May-2008 05:46 am (UTC)
Oh yes, trickster gods--I love them all! Loki is my favorite, though (obviously). <3

I always liked poor Balder too, and I like the story of Balder's death because it's so sad, and I like when Loki does horrible things as well as fun things. But what happens in the story is really so interesting (the story is set centuries after Balder's death)--it made me love Balder even more!

After Loki, the Aesir and Vanir were my favorite Norse figures, but I did like all the other non-humans, too (especially Loki's kids, awwwwww).

Yes, it was a fun read!

Edited at 2008-05-12 05:49 am (UTC)
This page was loaded May 16th 2008, 7:14 pm GMT.